Sunday, February 04, 2007

What Cammo Pattern?

[NOTE: Just for clarification, this is an old topic--see date above. The Regiment voted in early 2007 to adopt the ACU pattern as the standard. There is now further discussion of Companies adopting different patterns, and the merits of a new pattern called OmniPat, made by Special Ops Paintball.]

Uniforms:

My thought is to ensure each member of the Regt has the same pattern shirt/jacket--along with team patches. Whether we get matching pants for everyone is not as important, in my mind. That can come later.

To start, we should get a vote on going with the digital ACU (Army Combat Uniform) cammo pattern.

As a primer, here are the most prevalent cammo patterns, both in military use and the paintball/airsoft world. There are literally hundreds of other patterns, but these are the ones you hear about most.
  • Multicam This was the competitor to the ACU pattern, but lost. Multicam is not a digicammo pattern, but its very good and popular among airsoft clubs. It's also very expensive, at least $100 per set and up for a knockoff. The genuine stuff is more like $300 per set. Their website is impressive.
Here are the pros of ACUs, as I see them.

- Work well in our environment. With all the sage and scattered brush we have here, the ACU works very well. Better than DCU desert cammies, which are too light, and better than green/black/brown BDUs which are too dark.

- They also work passably well in heavier vegetation. It was designed as an all-around pattern.

- At night, or any reduced light environment, they work great. Early morning, or at dusk, they tend to disappear into whatever background you have.

- Digital patterns are the future. In a couple of years, the BDU and DCU patterns will be all phased out and will start looking dated. The US Army has invested big in ACUs, and you'll see more and more stuff made in this pattern. It is the "cool" thing going forward.

- There are some real technical advantage to a digital pattern, although I don't understand them all. Both the human eye, and modern sensors, have a harder time detecting them. And, EVEN when the subject is moving they're harder to detect. So I've read anyway.

- The real Army Rangers are using ACUs. So we should too.

Here are the cons.

- The biggest hit on the ACU pattern is that it's too light. In deep woods, that is true. They don't have enough black and green in them.

- MARPAT (the digi cammo the US Marines wear) is better. This may be true, especially where there is more vegetation. MARPAT has blacks and greens, so works better in the woods. For desert terrain, the Marines decided to use different pattern.

- There aren't a lot of accessories made in the ACU pattern yet. (True, but more appear every day.)

- There is a RUMOR, but with little to back it up, that the real Rangers may choose another cammo pattern in the future. If that were to happen, we could be stuck with an old pattern. To me that's a risk we have to take anyway.

So, let's get everyone's input on this. What do you guys think? Is ACU the pattern for us? I'm convinced it is, but I want to get a say from everyone.

6 comments:

  1. I think ACU is the way to go. Having made items from both the ACU and MARPAT materials the ACU ripstop is more dureable and of better quality. While the TriCam is interesting at a distance I feel that ACU will blend in just as well in most situations. I would like to point out that the pictures taken on the TriCam site were very heavily colored to favor the pattern. Tad and I have debated this... The other factor is if we eventually need to go to another pattern we could purchase it and also have our ACU for favoreable terrain. This would be beneficial if we travelled out of our area to places like D-Day which is very green and leafy. In our area though I think that the ACU is the most favorable option we have and as Tad said more items will be coming out in the new patterns as the material becomes more widely available.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My vote.......ACU.

    It works for this environment, and it is new enough to set us apart from run of the mill paintball players. Especially if we all have matching patches, It has an organized, almost intimidating look to it. And hey if everyone decides to go play in the dark forest, cross that bridge when we get to it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think we're going to have the majority favoring the ACUs. Does anyone have strong objections? Ryan?

    Next question: should we have the Regiment buy everyone an ACU top? That would be roughy $35 each, for about $350.

    Or should we have Regiment pay just a portion?--if so how much?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I would make the motion to have the Regiment purchase the uniform Top for Members of the Team.

    ReplyDelete
  5. OK, the consensus is to adopt the ACU cammo pattern for the Regiment -- and to go with the official ACU top (jacket/shirt) for everyone.

    Now we need to decide if the Regiment should pay the full $35 for each member -- or some portion of that.

    Oh, I just discovered a place to get these for $30--with the glint tape on the shoulder. That makes the decision easier.
    http://www.surpluscityonline.com/products.aspx?ProductID=104

    ReplyDelete
  6. I recently obtained the Omnipat after seeing it on one of the Ghost Echo crew and on Spec Ops. The one recommendation I have is that SpecOps has the Ultra Lite line of clothing. I have been wearing the "Elite Camo" version of the Ultra Lite's for about 6 months now and love it. If any of you have feel the Elite Camo was effective in hiding me during play, then the Omnipat will be as good if not better, especially for longer distance concealment. They have improved the style of the pants and jersey so they are tougher and more comfortable than previous renditions. Also having this style of uniform would make it alot easier to handle the heat we have most of the year. The ease of movement is also greater with this type of fabric due to its flexibility. BDU are tough but can be difficult to get yourself into positions without adjusting the pants or jacket. I was worried about durability with the UltraLites when I first got them but they have worn very tough with only a few small tears do to sprinting through a thorn bush... Overall for the cost $70, pattern (excellent), and heat alleviation, make these my choice for a uniform. As a side note Spec Ops is also throwing in a omnicam vest with purchase of a set of shirt and pants in omnipat. The vest retails for $90 so now is the time to get the stuff!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.